Creating a More Open Kitchen

Tredington Park Area, Tallahassee

White kitchen cabinets with wood accent on range hood

 

Elliot Holtom, Project Manager

 

Stephanie Jen, Designer

Total Cost: $137,739 ($6800 under budget before change orders requested by client)

Time To Complete: 8 Weeks (1 week longer than planned due to countertop delay)

Audio Summary:

Listen to a ‘podcast style’ review of this project. Press play below or listen on Spotify. 

Project Overview:

This 30 year old kitchen had served the family well but it was definitely time for an update. The 2 islands and peninsula made the kitchen feel crowded and broke up the counterspace too much. 

After some discussion we decided to change the layout, gettting rid of the 2 small islands and installing on larger one. We also removed the peninsula to open up the breakfast area and provide more natural light.

The big island created a perfect place to gather and provided lots of prep space. To do this we had to remove a window so we could move a range to that wall. But the window only looked out on to their garage wall and by removing the peninsula we were bringing more natural light into the space from the bay windows. 

Moving the range to the center also provided a great focal point, especially with the custom wood hood and full height Rose Bay Quartz backsplash. 

In addition to the kitchen remodel we replaced all the flooring downstairs and painted the downstairs and loft area. 

Updating An Architect Designed Kitchen: Before/After

Drag the slider to see this project transformation!

The peninsula was blocking the natural light and closing the breakfast area off from the kitchen

McManus Kitchen and Bath is a full service remodeling company with an in-house design team and showroom right here in Tallahassee, FL. Contact us to schedule a consult. 

Dishwasher drawers

Dual fuel range with two ovens

Built in coffee maker and microwave

High volume range hood

Opened up breakfast area and added new lighting

Key Updates:

  • Whole house flooring (downstairs)
  • Wolf built in coffee maker
  • Matching Quartz Backsplash
  • Large island with seating

Quote from the client:

“Everything is going so smoothly, it’s been a great experience, your team is fantastic!” 

Initial Concept and Budget

The initial design and budget consult includes 3D concept drawings and a good better best budget for your project.

This gives us a pretty good idea of what the project might look like but your designer continue to explore options during the deisgn process. 

Before Plan

The original kitchen had two islands and a penisula. This left the kitchen feeling a bit crowded and it cut off the breakfast area from the rest of the house, blocking light form the 3 bay windows.

Architect Designed Kitchen Before

Before: Two island and a peninsula

Architect designed kitchen after renovation

First concept: Large island with seating, expand kitchen 

Initial Concept

The initial concept inlcuded single large island and getting rid of the peninsula so we could expand the kitchen.

It would mean removing the window over the sink so we could put the range there and moving the sink into the island. 

The Initial Budget: $144,605

During the review of our ‘good better best’ budget the client choose our better cabinet line, Decor and opted for quartz countertops.

Other selections were a mix of good and better options. The budget included painting the entire downstairs and replacing all the flooring downstairs. 

Good Better Best Budget estimate for a kitchen

Partial image of the inital budget for Concept 1

Design and Planning

After you have approved your initial concept and budget the design process begins, starting with our designers visiting your home.

We have between 2-4 design meetings in our showroom to finalize all the details of the project, including a fixed price contract and a detailed project calendar.

Updated Design

The final design is similar to the initial concept but with significant refinements. The designers added a pantry cabinet and built in coffee maker. 

They also expanding the island slightly and added box fillers. Of course they dialed in all the colors, fixtures and materials. 

3D kitchen design

The Final Proposal: $137,739 ($6800 less than initial budget)

During design we are also getting pricing from labor and materials from our trade partners so we can create your fixed price proposal.

For this project the final cost was slightly slower than the intial budget. The main reason was the removed the painting of the downstairs. During the project however they would wind up adding that back in. 

 

Materials and Fixtures

Our Favorite Things

When designing a project we always to try create between 1 and 3 focal points to draw the eye. Then we arrange other points of interest throughout the space.

Every project has a few things that really make it stand our or were special to the homeowner. Here are our favorites.

Workstation sink in kitchen island

Ruvati Workstation Sink (and that gorgeous countertop) 

Wolf coffee makers and built in microwave

Wolf Integrated Coffee Maker (and the matching quartz backsplash)

Pullout organizer

Pullout Utensil Organizer

Dishwasher drawers

Dishwasher Drawers

Materials and Fixtures Used in This Project

Cabinets and Counters

    • Frameless Cabinets by Decor Cabinets.
      • MDF875 Door 
      • Custom paint – White Dove
      • Island finish – Black Panther
      • Organizers: Trash pullout, Spice pullout, Utensil pullout, Rollouts in pantry, tray dividers over fridge
      • Riverside Pulls, Flat Black from Top Knobs
    • Cambria Rose Bay Quartz countertop and backsplash installed by Southern Tops

     Flooring and Tile

      • Coretec Springfield OakLVP Flooring

    Fixtures and Accessories

      • Ruvati Roma 32″ Worstation Sink
      • Brizo Pre-Rinse Faucet
      • Brizo Air switch for disposal
      • Stealth 750 Disposal from Mountain Plumbing
      • 3000K Wafer Lights in ceiling
      • Arren Black Round Pendants from Crate and Barrel over breakfast table
      • Urban Globe Dining Room Light from Shades of Light
      • Undercabinet lights from Task Lighting
      • Decora plugs and switches

    Appliances

      • GE Cafe Smart Slide in Dual Fuel Double Oven Range
      • Wolf EC2450TES Coffee Maker
      • GE Cafe Double Drawer Dishwasher

    Project Challenges and Solutions

    A few things about they way we run our projects:

    Proactive Communication is Crucial: We prioritizes consistent and transparent communication. We provide regular updates through various channels like on-site meetings, phone calls, and detailed daily logs. This approach helps manage expectations and address concerns promptly.

    Detailed Documentation Ensures Transparency and Accountability: Our daily logs offer a comprehensive record of project progress, issues encountered, and their resolutions. This meticulous documentation is invaluable for identifying potential problems, tracking decisions, and ensuring accountability among the project team and subcontractors.

    Effective Subcontractor Coordination is Key: A significant aspect of the project involves managing various subcontractors. Precise scheduling, clear communication, and quality control ensure a smooth workflow and a successful outcome.

    Problem-Solving is an Ongoing Process: It is important to have a proactive and adaptable approach to problem-solving in project management.

    Punch Lists Facilitate Project Completion: The use of a daily punch list helps to systematically identify and track outstanding items, ensuring that even minor details are addressed before project closure.

    Kitchen island with sink
    Range and fridge in new kitchen

    Challenges And Solutions During Construction

    Every project has its mix of large and small issues to deal with. Having a project manager who is on site every day helps avoid them but also deal with issues quickly when they are discovered. Here are a list of things from our daily logs on this project:

    Minor Issues, easliy addressed:

    • The trash can pull-out required multiple adjustments before it functioned properly. Initially, it needed a push to close correctly. A replacement slide clip was ordered and installed, but the issue persisted. Finally, a second replacement clip successfully resolved the problem.
    • The ceiling fan’s electrical setup posed challenges. The wiring did not allow for the light and fan to be controlled independently. We did not install the fan but the client was expecting us to update the switch, not understanding what was involved.  Our electrican were able to resovle the issue and we took care of it at our expense.  
    • A minor ding appeared on the upper dishwasher drawer front, necessitating a warranty replacement from the supplier, Bobby Dollar. The contractor notified Bobby Dollar and expected the replacement to be handled as a warranty item.
    • Locating a suitable position for the disposal air switch was not decided during the design phase. The issue was resovled quickly after a discussion with the client.
    • A pre-existing speaker box in the wall presented a cosmetic issue. The solution involved covering it with a blank plate and touching up the surrounding paint.
    • A pre-existing wafer light near the bathroom stopped functioning and required attention. This issue was noted and the electrican replaced the light.
    • The floor plug inserts brought by the electricians did not fit the installed boxes, demanding a return trip to complete the task. This was a minor issue but we made note to check compatibility of floor boxes in the future.
    • Confusion arose regarding the responsibility for installing a slide mechanism for the Wolf coffee maker. The electricians did not feel comfortable performing the installation. We called our carpenter back to site to install it for them. 

    Two Major Issues

    One caused a delay in the project by about a week. The other was just frustrating.

    • Miscommunication with Bobby Dollar regarding appliance installation caused scheduling conflicts. The project manager initially understood that Bobby Dollar would install the appliances, but later learned that this was not the case, requiring the plumbers to be rescheduled. This was a miscommunication between the design and the project manager. They have both recognized it and will do better in the future.
    • Countertop delay. Countertop install was delayed due to material availability. This sometimes happen with unique selection like their Rose Bay Quartz from Cambria. There was nothing any of us could do but wait.

      Project Timeline and Final Costs

      Project Timeline

      The project started right on time. We only had one major delay caused by a longer lead time to get the countertop material. The project finsihed about a week later than planned. 

      • Proposed project start date: Nov. 14th 2023

      • Actual Project Start Date: Nov 14th 2023

      • Proposed Completion Date: June 28th, 2023

      • Actual Completion Date: July 8th, 2023

      Project schedule for an architect designed kitchen

      We create detailed project calendars for each project to set expections and keep things running on time. You can access these calendars in your project portal. The project manager updates them daily.

      Summary of Project Costs

      Initial Estimate:  $144,609

      Fixed price proposal: $137,739 ($6870 under budget)

      Reasons for increase/Decrease: Labor costs for this project came in a little lower than expected. A few changes in material selections, like changing from porcelain tile to marble, caused the price to increase.

      Change Orders: $11,930

      These were all additions to the scope of work requested by the client. The largest was painting the entire downstairs and loft.

      FInal Project Cost: $149,670

      Includes all change orders

        Cost Breakdown

        • Installation Labor 27% 27%
        • Materials and Fixtures 25% 25%
        • Design and Project Management Costs 20% 20%
        • Sales Tax and Shipping 4% 4%
        • Overhead and Profit 10% 10%
        • Change Orders 8% 8%

        Project Photos and Video

        Project Video

        View all project videos on our YouTube channel: View Video Playlist

        Project Highlight Reel

        Client Thoughts on Project Management

        Before Photos

        Final Project Photos

        Final Thoughts

        We love projects like this. Projects where we can add value not only in the look of the space but improve the layout and function as well. This couple was a joy to work this and we’ve already started planning the next project with them. 

        Estimate from a Remodeling Contractor

        Explore Idea, Understand Options on Costs

        Our Design and Budget Consult Provides

          • 3D drawings to help you visualize options
          • A detailed estimate of materials and labor
          • A chance to review material and fixture options in our showroom